December 18, 2004

White Shoe

by PG

I've wondered for some time about what exactly the phrase "white shoe firm" means. My Torts professor just used it in reference to the opposing counsel in A Civil Action (which he calls "one of the best nonfiction books I've read in the last decade"). I raised my hand to ask and then put it down when I remembered that this was a review session and not supposed to be taken up with stupid non-exam related questions.

But who needs a respectable source of knowledge when there's the internet? First I consulted dictionary.com, which offered American Heritage's "Of or being a long-established business known for reputable service and a wealthy clientele: 'took a job at... [a] pronouncedly white-shoe investment-banking firm' (Connie Bruck)" and WordNet's "denoting a company or law firm owned and run by members of the WASP elite who are generally conservative; 'the politician tried to hide his white-shoe background.'"

This was the general understanding that I had of the term, but it didn't explain its origin. On to the OED, which had a very different take:

white-shoe slang (chiefly U.S.), effeminate, immature [...]
1957 J. D. SALINGER Zooey
Phooey, I say, on all *white-shoe college boys who edit their campus literary magazines. Give me an honest con man any day.
1974 G. JENKINS Bridge of Magpies vi. 85
What sort of white~shoe captain are you?
1975 N.Y. Times 22 Sept. 33/1
Covert operations can be stripped from the CIA... So can such monkey business as dropping simulated poison cannisters in the New York subways -- the games of white-shoe boys who never grew up.
This attempt to track the meaning comes to the best conclusion:

Ivy League collegians. Thus a 'white shoe firm' is one primarily staffed by such individuals (rather than one which employs Jews, Blacks or other minorities). The implication is of traditionalism, stuffiness, etc. White shoe, in more general slang, and with the same etymology, means immature or effeminate. [[interestingly enough Merrill-Lynchís present Chairman, President, Chief Executive & Chief Operating Officer is a Black graduate of Harvard Business School]].

WHITE-SHOE adjective: 1) [1975-1980] of or pertaining to members of the upper class who own or run large corporations; of the U.S. establishment: 'white-shoe bankers'; 'white-shoe law firms'; 'a conservative white-shoe image.' [from the white shoes popular as moderately formal wear among suburban men circa 1980 and also from the earlier Ivy League usage 2) a typical Ivy League student; having or affecting the dress, manners, attitudes, etc. of the Ivy League [popular at Princeton at varying intervals since circa 1915; general student use circa 1945-55 only. From the white buckskin shoes that were part of the typical studentís dress].

However, this site gives a different time period for the popularity of white shoes.

"White-shoe," as a reference to Ivy League background, is a much more accurate term to use for contemporary elite institutions than "WASP" or "good ol' boy," both of which no longer describe the set of people who currently constitute The Man. The generation that attended Harvard after the collapse of anti-minority quotas and with the advent of affirmative action is now in power, and they are frequently Jewish, Catholic and/ or female (and to a lesser extent, people of color). At the same time, the old investment and law firms still require the white-shoe educational pedigree as much as they ever did.

(This isn't very relevant, but it's funny. Y.P.R. -- a McSweeney's wannabe?)

December 18, 2004 06:42 PM | TrackBack
Comments

Wow- I come to the opposite conclusion. I summered at a large white shoe corporate law firm (defense side), which taught me that I didn't want corporate law firm, large, or white shoe environment. And I was ivy league, to the bone, although not the kind who wore white shoes. Ivy college, ivy law school. But who were these people, in this largely conservative defense-side firm? WASPs, largely. Dominated by Jews, Hispanics, and Blacks? Um... not exactly.

Incidentally, i notice both of those silly quotes from the OED pair "white shoe" in the sense of Ivy College-educated, entitled, Princetonian (if one will), with the separate concept of Boys, as in immature. Thus, boys + white shoe = entitled or WASPy boys. Not in itself immature. Possibly effeminate, but that's not my take.

A white shoe firm is respectable; a white shoe firm is high-minded. A white shoe firm, id est, is conservative and historically snooty. Not like those dirty brown-shoe firms.

Posted by: enonymous at December 28, 2004 04:24 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?






Sitting in Review
Armen (e-mail) #
PG (e-mail) #
Craig Konnoth (e-mail) #
About Us
Senior Status